Skip to content

Guide · Machines

Alchemy Factory machines compared: which to build in 1.1

Only one later machine is a pure speed upgrade: the Enhanced Grinder runs every Grinder recipe twice as fast, though it needs more floor per item. The Stackable Crucible, Thermal Extractor and Advanced Athanor also run their base machine's recipes but trade heat or space for what they add. Seven “Advanced” or “Arcane” machines share no recipe with the machine they are named after.

Updated for v1.1.5024Published

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Crucible vs Stackable Crucible
  3. Grinder vs Enhanced Grinder
  4. Extractor vs Thermal Extractor
  5. Athanor vs Advanced Athanor
  6. Alembic vs Advanced Alembic
  7. Cauldron vs Advanced Cauldron
  8. Advanced and Arcane machines
  9. The Refiner
  10. The Paradox Crucible
  11. The Kiln
  12. FAQ
  13. Related guides
  14. Tools for this

The short answer

Each pair at a glance; the sections below have the numbers.

Machine pairs: what changes and when to build
Base → later machineWhat changesBuild it
Grinder → Enhanced GrinderSame recipes; twice as fast; 3×1 instead of 1×1Where you have the room; Grinders pack tighter
Crucible → Stackable CrucibleSame recipes; passes heat up; 6 P/s instead of 4; 3×1 instead of 2×1Only to heat a machine stacked on top
Extractor → Thermal ExtractorSame recipes; up to 3× output, by height; 80 P/s of heat; 2×1 instead of 1×1Built high, to save inputs and space
Athanor → Advanced AthanorFour extra recipes; takes catalysts; 32 P/s on Athanor recipes, 360 P/s on its own; 3×3 instead of 2×2For its own recipes or catalysts
Alembic → Advanced AlembicNo shared recipes; 270 P/s instead of 108; 2×2 instead of 2×1Next to the Alembics, for its own recipes
Cauldron → Advanced CauldronNo listed recipes; two ingredients instead of threeFor two-ingredient brews
Blender, Assembler, Shaper and Processor → Advanced or ArcaneNo shared recipesNext to the base machines, for their own recipes

Heat is the in-game Heat Consuming Speed, in P (Pyra) per second, at base speed. The machine heat table lists every machine, and the planner counts machines for a whole chain. The late-game guide has a shorter version of this page.

In short

Swap Grinders for Enhanced Grinders where you have the floor space. Everything else is a trade: check what you give up before you replace a base machine.

Crucible vs Stackable Crucible

The Stackable Crucible runs the same 9 recipes as the Crucible at the same speed, but draws 6 P/s instead of 4 P/s: 1.5 times as much heat per item. Its footprint is 3×1 instead of 2×1.

What it adds is in its in-game description: it is a heater that passes heat to the machine above it. The Crucible's description says it can only be built on a furnace; the Stackable Crucible's doesn't. It unlocks at the Workbench, not in the research tree, after Bronze Rivet research (Level VI).

Crucible and Stackable Crucible side by side
SpecCrucibleStackable Crucible
Recipes9The same
Speed×1×1
Heat4 P/s6 P/s
Size (x×y×z)2×1×13×1×1
Build costStone ×4Stone ×6, Steel Ingot ×2, Bronze Rivet ×2
UnlockCrucible research (Level IV), 1 silver 600 copperWorkbench, after Bronze Rivet research (Level VI)

In short

For smelting, keep Crucibles: smaller, cheaper to fuel. Build a Stackable Crucible where you want to stack a heated machine on top of it.

Grinder vs Enhanced Grinder

The Enhanced Grinder runs all 18 Grinder recipes twice as fast, and neither draws heat. One does the work of two Grinders, so its belt has to carry twice as many items.

The catch is space: its footprint is 3×1 against the Grinder's 1×1, so per floor cell it grinds only two thirds as much. It unlocks at the Workbench after Steel Gear research (Level V).

Grinder and Enhanced Grinder side by side
SpecGrinderEnhanced Grinder
Recipes18The same
Speed×1×2
HeatNoneNone
Size (x×y×z)1×1×13×1×1
Build costPlank ×6Plank ×12, Steel Gear ×3
UnlockGrinder research (Level I), 100 copperWorkbench, after Steel Gear research (Level V)

In short

This is the one pure speed upgrade: swap once Steel Gears flow and you have the room. On a crowded floor, Grinders pack tighter.

Extractor vs Thermal Extractor

The Thermal Extractor runs every Extractor recipe at the same speed. Its in-game description says the higher it is built, the more it makes. Community calculators (opens in a new tab) multiply its output by 1 + 2 × min(height, 255) ÷ 255: nothing extra at the bottom, twice the output at height 127.5 and 3× from height 255 up. Players measured about 15 of those height units per floor, so the cap comes at about floor 17; treat the heights here as a guide.

More output from the same input means fewer inputs. At the cap, each product needs a third of the input, which matters most for Fairy Dust (a Level IX ingredient) turned into Fairy Tear. The price is heat: 80 P/s where the Extractor needs none, about 7.27 Coke Powder a minute, and a 2×1 footprint against 1×1. So below height 127.5 (about 8.5 floors up), two Extractors in the same floor space make more, with no fuel.

It unlocks at the Workbench after Alembic research (Level VII), not in the research tree.

Extractor and Thermal Extractor side by side
SpecExtractorThermal Extractor
Recipes5The same
Speed×1×1
HeatNone80 P/s
Output×1×1 to ×3, by height
Size (x×y×z)1×1×22×1×2
Build costIron Ingot ×5, Glass ×5Steel Ingot ×5, Glass ×5
UnlockExtractor research (Level IV), 1 silver 600 copperWorkbench, after Alembic research (Level VII)

In short

Build Thermal Extractors high up, for the inputs that are slow to make. Low down, plain Extractors do the job without fuel.

Athanor vs Advanced Athanor

The Advanced Athanor runs all 5 Athanor recipes plus four of its own (Silver Powder, Obsidian, Lapis Lazuli and Gold Dust), at the same speed. Its own recipes draw 360 P/s, about 11 times as much as the Athanor's 32 P/s. Its in-game description says Athanor recipes keep the Athanor's heat, so moving them to an Advanced Athanor costs no extra fuel.

It is also the machine where catalysts take effect (where catalysts work). Athanor recipes can fail. The Athanor has two belt outputs, and its in-game description says failed products leave through the second; the Advanced Athanor has three, and its Lapis Lazuli and Gold Dust can each fail into two different items. It is also bigger: 3×3×5 against 2×2×3.

Athanor and Advanced Athanor side by side
SpecAthanorAdvanced Athanor
Recipes55 shared + 4 own
Speed×1×1
Heat32 P/s32 P/s on Athanor recipes, 360 P/s on its own
Size (x×y×z)2×2×33×3×5
Build costIron Ingot ×10, Iron Nails ×15Steel Ingot ×12, Copper Ingot ×12
UnlockAthanor research (Level V), 4 silver 400 copperAdvanced Athanor research (Level VIII), 1 gold 36 silver

In short

Build Advanced Athanors for their own recipes and for catalysts. For plain Coke and Steel Ingot without catalysts, the Athanor does the same work in less space.

Alembic vs Advanced Alembic

Despite the name, the Advanced Alembic runs none of the Alembic's recipes. The Alembic makes Lavender Essential Oil, Brandy and Sulfuric Acid at 108 P/s; the Advanced Alembic makes Quicksilver, Aqua Vitae and Moon Tear at 270 P/s, 2.5 times as much. Quicksilver takes Sulfuric Acid and Aqua Vitae takes Brandy, both Alembic products, so the Advanced Alembic adds to your Alembics rather than replacing them.

Both have to sit on a furnace. Every product of both is a liquid and leaves by pipe. The Alembic's top output is 480 Brandy a minute.

Alembic and Advanced Alembic recipes
ProductMachinePer minuteHeat
Lavender Essential OilAlembic300108 P/s
BrandyAlembic480108 P/s
Sulfuric AcidAlembic300108 P/s
QuicksilverAdvanced Alembic75270 P/s
Aqua VitaeAdvanced Alembic75270 P/s
Moon TearAdvanced Alembic7.5270 P/s

In short

Build both. The Advanced Alembic is a next step that feeds on Alembics, not an upgrade.

Cauldron vs Advanced Cauldron

The Advanced Cauldron takes two ingredients where the Cauldron takes three, and the game lists no recipes for it: it works out the product in-game. How it picks one is in the catalysts and cauldrons guide (the Advanced Cauldron).

The Cauldron keeps the game's own listed recipes: Philosopher's Stone, Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald (best cauldron recipes). Its heat depends on the brew: about 101 to 167 P/s for those, on the curve community calculators use (opens in a new tab). There is no such estimate for the Advanced Cauldron. Both take a 3×3 footprint.

Cauldron and Advanced Cauldron side by side
SpecCauldronAdvanced Cauldron
Recipes4None listed
Speed×1×1
Heat101–167 P/s, by recipeNot listed
Size (x×y×z)3×3×23×3×2
Build costBronze Ingot ×20Silver Ingot ×20
UnlockCauldron research (Level VI), 12 silverAdvanced Cauldron research (Level VIII), 1 gold 36 silver

In short

It is a different tool, not a better Cauldron. Keep Cauldrons for the listed recipes; use the Advanced Cauldron for two-ingredient brews. Test a pair in the Cauldron finder first.

Advanced and Arcane machines: upgrades or not?

Not upgrades. None of these runs a recipe of the machine it is named after, so they never replace the Blenders, Assemblers, Shapers and Processors: each has its own recipes. All of them work at base speed and draw no heat, like their base machines.

Advanced and Arcane machines and their recipes
MachineNamed afterSharedIts own recipesUnlock
Advanced BlenderBlender0Black Powder, Growth Potion, Blast Potion, Fertile Catalyst, Resonant Catalyst and Panacea PotionAdvanced Blender research (Level VI)
Advanced AssemblerAssembler0Pocket Watch, Clockwork Bird and CrownAdvanced Assembler research (Level VI)
Advanced ShaperShaper0Venus, Mercury and LunaAdvanced Shaper research (Level VII)
Arcane ShaperShaper0SolArcane Shaper research (Level IX)
Arcane ProcessorProcessor0Eternal Catalyst, Star Dust and Fairy DustArcane Processor research (Level IX)

The Arcane Shaper's Sol takes the Shaper's Jupiter, Saturn and Mars (making Sol). The Arcane Shaper is the largest of them at 9×9 cells, against 3×3 for the Shaper, so leave room before you research it.

In short

Keep every base machine. Build the Advanced and Arcane ones next to them, for the recipes only they run.

The Refiner

The Refiner has no base or advanced version. It runs 21 recipes that each turn two of an item into one of the next grade, with no heat and no fail chance. It climbs the shard ladder from Crude Shard to Perfect Diamond in eight steps, so one Perfect Diamond takes 256 Crude Shards (do diamonds pay?).

It is also where many Athanor fail products go. It takes Sand, Crude Shard, Shattered Crystal, Crude Silver Powder, Crude Gold Dust, Impure Copper Powder and Impure Gold Dust, which failed Salt, Malachite, Lapis Lazuli, Silver Powder, Gold Dust and Copper Powder crafts leave behind, and refines each a grade up.

Crude Shard, Pure Gold Dust, Copper Powder, Silver Powder and Gold Dust also have recipes on other machines; the planner compares the routes.

In short

Build a Refiner (Refiner research, Level VI) for shards and diamonds, and put one next to your Athanors to refine what their failed crafts leave.

The Paradox Crucible

The Paradox Crucible draws 1,200 P/s, the highest Heat Consuming Speed the game lists: about 3.33 times as much as the Advanced Athanor, the next hungriest. At base Heat Value that is about 109.1 Coke Powder a minute for one machine (heat and fuel guide). Only a Steam Boiler on its High setting draws more: community research puts it at 3,000 P/s.

Despite its name, it runs no Crucible recipe. Its two listed recipes turn Oblivion Essence into Vitality Essence and back, one for one, 12 a minute. Its in-game description adds that other materials can be refined into Oblivion Essence too, each at its own speed. It is 3×3×3 and needs Paradox Crucible research (Level VII).

In short

Build only as many as your essence needs, and plan its fuel line before you place it.

The Kiln

The Kiln is the only machine that makes Brick and Glass, so every factory needs one. It draws 15 P/s, sits on a furnace and takes a 3×3 footprint (machines per furnace).

Its other three recipes melt coins into Copper Ingot, Silver Ingot and Gold Ingot; they come with the Copper Coin Mint License, Silver Coin Mint License and Gold Coin Mint License. Crucibles make the same ingots from metal powder.

The Stone Furnace, Blast Furnace and Iron Smelter are a smelting question, outside this comparison (smelting guide).

In short

You need a Kiln for Brick and Glass. Its coin recipes need a Mint License; for ingots from powder, use Crucibles.

FAQ

Is the Stackable Crucible better than the Crucible?

Not for smelting. It runs the same recipes at the same speed but draws 6 P/s instead of 4 P/s and takes a 3×1 footprint instead of 2×1. Its point is that it passes heat to the machine built on top of it. It unlocks at the Workbench after Bronze Rivet research (Level VI).

Is the Enhanced Grinder worth it?

Yes, where you have the room. It runs all 18 Grinder recipes twice as fast with no heat, so one replaces two Grinders. It costs Plank ×12, Steel Gear ×3 and unlocks at the Workbench after Steel Gear research (Level V). Its footprint is 3×1 against 1×1, so per floor cell it grinds only two thirds as much: on a crowded floor, keep Grinders.

How much more does a Thermal Extractor make?

More the higher you build it. Community calculators multiply its output by 1 + 2 × min(height, 255) ÷ 255: nothing extra at the bottom, twice an Extractor's output at height 127.5 and 3× from height 255 up. Players measured about 15 height units per floor, so the cap comes at about floor 17. It runs at the same speed as an Extractor but draws 80 P/s, about 7.27 Coke Powder a minute.

Does the Advanced Athanor use more heat on Athanor recipes?

No. Its in-game description says so, and the game lists Athanor recipes at 32 P/s in both machines. Its own four recipes draw 360 P/s, about 11 times as much.

Does the Advanced Alembic replace the Alembic?

No. They share no recipe: the Alembic makes Lavender Essential Oil, Brandy and Sulfuric Acid, the Advanced Alembic Quicksilver, Aqua Vitae and Moon Tear. Quicksilver takes Sulfuric Acid and Aqua Vitae takes Brandy, so you need both.

What does the Refiner do?

It turns two of an item into one of the next grade, with no heat and no fail chance: shards to crystals to diamonds, and metal powders up a grade. A Perfect Diamond takes 256 Crude Shards over eight steps. It also takes the fail products of Athanor recipes, such as Sand and Crude Shard.

Tools for this

Spotted a mistake? Numbers on this page match v1.1.5024 of the game. If your game shows something different, tell us.

Search